What are Edward de Bono’s Six Thinking Hats®?
Drawing from Bill Jarrard
www.fuzz2buzz.com
Edward de Bono designed six hats to help structure and scaffold thinking about a topic. “Using the Six Thinking Hats® forces the thinker to consider the problem in several dimensions, and is more likely to guarantee better thinking” (Frengenheim 2010, p.52). The six hats are:
White Hat (facts, questions)
Yellow Hat (positive, why it will work, success)
Red Hat (feelings intuitions)
Black Hat (caution, weak points)
Green Hat (creative, alternatives)
Blue Hat (overview, summary) (Frengenheim, 2010, p.51).
After doing some research on google, it is evident that Edward de Bono’s Six Thinking Hats® are being used across a wide variety of sectors from education to business.
Further information can be found at the following websites:
http://www.edwdebono.com/
http://www.kurwongbss.eq.edu.au/thinking/Hats/hats.htm
What learning theories did the wiki use?
The design of the wiki using Edward de Bono’s Six Thinking Hats® fits within the principles of Social Constructivism and Connectivism theory.
“The constructivist approach is based on the premise that, by reflecting on our own experiences, we construct our own understanding of the world we live in” (EDED20456 Pedagogical Content Knowledge Reading 2.2, p.8). Constructivist theory requires us to look at whole topics/issues (Thirteen ed online, 2004) and be engaged with others (The Institute for Learning Centre Education, n.d.).
“A constructivist lesson challenges students to address one of the higher level thinking skills between comprehension and evaluation (in other words, to go beyond simple "recall" of information” (The Institute for Learning Centre Education, n.d.).
Using the five principles of applying constructivism in the classroom I found on the Thirteen ed online website, I will discuss how the wiki activity fits within Constructivism Theory. Thirteen ed online (2004) describes the 5 principles as:
Principle 1. Pose problems that are or will be relevant to the students.
The wiki and topic presented to us, was relevant to our learning within ICT’s for Learning Design subject. As pre-service teachers we need to explore the different technological tools within the classroom to engage and help students gain a deeper understanding of topics/issues.
Principle 2. Structure learning around essential concepts.
We were given the overall topic ‘Mobile Phones - Should they be used in the classroom?’ The Six Thinking Hats® tool then allowed us to break the topic into smaller chucks of information.
Principle 3. Be aware that students’ points of view are windows into their reasoning.
The Six Thinking Hats allowed us to be open ended with our discussions and explain our points of view. Principle 3. talks about using evidence or proof of the opinion, which I did not do but could have easily added to my discussion through referencing information.
Principle 4. Adapt curriculum to address students’ suppositions and development .
What we were required to do with the wiki fitted our developmental level as adults. With children this would be more important and relate to their potential development (Culatta, 2012) as well as their age, year level and expectation of the National Curriculum and Queensland’s Essential Learnings within the Key Learning Areas.
Principle 5. Assess student learning in the context of teaching.
Assessment is most useful when it is meaningful. We are assessing ourselves through completing this reflective blog which is meaningful to us.
Scaffolding this experience through a learning tool such as the Six Thinking Hats®, helps students to organise their thinking. It centres the learning on the learner rather than the teacher which fits in well with constructivist thinking.
Using a wiki also aligns well with a social constructivist principle of engaging with others. While the next step of actually refining the ideas as a group was not completed, each student was engaging with other students ideas through reading. Ideally the ideas presented would be refined in a group setting. The end product would be a student owned set of ideas to add to, learn from, research and design new ideas from. To involve higher order thinking skills, lesson plans with mobile phones being used could be designed and research completed into the effectiveness of them in the class room.
The use of the Wiki as a learning tool also has characteristics that fit within the Connectivism Learning theory. Siemens (2005, p. 4) says:
Learning is a process that occurs within nebulous environments of shifting core elements – not entirely under the control of the individual. Learning (defined as actionable knowledge) can reside outside of ourselves (within an organisation or a database), is focused on connecting specialised information sets, and the connections that enable us to learn more are more important than our current state of knowing.
The wiki helps students to engage with each other, connect information and create meaning from the information in the hats. The wiki, hats and group work activities align with connectivism theory in the following way:
· Connection to others,
· different opinions,
· connecting of data and information sources,
· internet research and link to relevant documents added,
· students to make connections between ideas,
· up to date information to be added,
· critical reflection on what information should be kept or discarded (if the information was collated).
What was it like participating in the Wiki using Edward de Bono’s Six Thinking Hats®?
I am going to use the PMI framework to reflect on using the wiki with The Six Thinking Hats®.
From my point of view (The Learner)
Plus |
Minus |
Interesting |
The hats gave me a starting point for my thoughts. Helped scaffold my learning. |
That by looking at other people’s ideas first without forming your own ideas you are at risk of adding the same information and not thinking deeper - I decided to look at each of the hats separately on my own and then add my ideas to the wiki. I then read everyone’s comments which gave me more ideas to write about. |
New tool for me to learn. |
Wiki allowed for collaboration with the class. |
There were difficulties saving information when 2 people were using it at once. |
That the tools are available now for people to work and add to the same project. |
Learn from what others had written. |
||
Gives a larger information base. |
||
The Six Thinking Hats® allow for a topic to be deconstructed into smaller parts of understanding. |
||
Allows for all points of views to be put forward. Helps students to see other points of view. |
||
Incorporates all learning styles. |
(PMI framework sourced from Frangenheim, 2010,
p. 40)
How does the scaffold support the collection
of a range of perspectives?
Edward de Bono’s Six Thinking Hats®
supports and scaffolds students learning.
A framework helps you to think about a topic more deeply by providing specific
areas and questions to look at. You are asked about the facts (white hat), how
you feel emotionally about the topic (red hat), asked to critically look at the
dangers (black hat), the benefits (yellow hat), creative thinking about new
ideas or alternatives and what to do next (blue hat). Through the use of a wiki and the hats
framework a larger range of student answers are given. It also allows students to learn from each
other.
How could this strategy support the learning
of my future students?
The use of Edward de Bono’s Six Thinking Hats®
within a wiki format allows for students to gain a deeper understanding of a
topic by looking at it from a number of angles.
It provides enough support for students to understand what is required (the
scaffolding), while allowing for freedom to add what they think is
important. Students own the information,
so they are more likely to be engaged in the process. When students are adding information to a
wiki, they are also learning from each other.
If the range of responses was also discussed and the information was
organised into more distinct chunks by working in groups, the students would
then be able to start thinking about how it could be used.
Using a wiki format, with the Six Thinking Hats® and
group discussions supports the range of student learning styles (Felder and Solomon, n.d.) including:
- visual (Six Thinking Hats® table format),
- verbal (written words and discussion in groups),
- active (applying information to the table and group work),
- reflective learners (time to think and add to the wiki on own) ,
- sensing (adding and thinking in an ordered way, structure to follow),
- intuitive learners (connections and discoveries can be made from the ideas presented and the questions asked),
- sequential (the hats provide an order to work in),and
- global learners (‘Big Picture’ is provided).
If a range of styles are supported within a lesson, students
are more likely to be engaged, comprehend and make meaning from the information
presented.
In conclusion, overall I found this activity very
engaging and easy to follow due to the use of Edward de Bono’s Six Thinking
Hats®.
References
Culatta, R. (2012). Social Development Theory (L. Vygotsky). Retrieved from http://www.instructionaldesign.org/theories/social-development.html
EDED20456 Pedagogical Content Knowledge Reading 2.2, p.8.
EDED20456 Pedagogical Content Knowledge Reading 2.2, p.8.
Felder, R. M, and Solomon, B. A. (n.d.). Learning Styles and Strategies. Retrieved from http://www4.ncsu.edu/unity/lockers/users/f/felder/public/ILSdir/styles.htm
Frangenheim,E. (2010). Reflections on classroom thinking strategies. Loganholme,
Queensland:Rodin Educational Publishing.
Siemens, G. (2005).Connectivism:
A Learning Theory for the Digital Age. Elearnspace Retrieved from http://www.elearnspace.org/Articles/connectivism.htm
The Institute for Learning Centered Education. (n.d.) Constructivism? A Definition. Retrieved from http://www.learnercentereded.org/constr_what.html
Thirteen ed online. (2004) Workshop: Constructivism as a Paradigm for Teaching and Learning. Retrieved from http://www.thirteen.org/edonline/concept2class/constructivism/index.html
Thirteen ed online. (2004) Workshop: Constructivism as a Paradigm for Teaching and Learning. Retrieved from http://www.thirteen.org/edonline/concept2class/constructivism/index.html
·
No comments:
Post a Comment