Friday, 30 March 2012

Appendix E - Group 3 Technologies -Prezi

This week we looked at presentation technologies which included PowerPoint, Prezi and Glogster.  This reflection is going to focus on Prezi and then compare it to PowerPoint.

Here is the example I made: 


I found after a bit of playing around with the program that it was quite easy to use.  Once you know what each button does and you understand how to link (path) each section together it will flow from one section to the next.  I did find however that I had to go over the order after it was published because for some reason it missed out a couple of steps. It also took me a few goes to understand how to embed videos. 

I have decided to critique this tool in the form of a PMI.

 Use of a Prezi in the Classroom
 PLUS
 MINUS
 INTERESTING
  •  Can create linear and non linear presentations.
  • Can zoom in and out on images or text.
  • Multi-dimensional.
  • Information does not have to be in dot form.
  • Information can be put together in its relationship to each other 
  • Can embed digital video, u-tube videos and digital images.
  • Can be set up to play itself.
  • Has the WOW factor. 
  • Can be edited by up to 8 people.
  • Can be accessed from any computer.
  • You can send a Prezi to a non Prezi user.
  • Took me a long time to set up (I am sure with practise I would get faster).
  • Can make you feel sick watching one if it is speed through and there are to many steps and turns.
  • Information needs to be succinct and to the main points.
  • Its a lot like PowerPoint. Have to have a reason why to  use it instead of PowerPoint. 
  • If students are working collaboratively on a Prezi they need to be aware that they can delete others work.
  •  When I first watched a demonstration of one I thought WOW!.  It made reading the information much more interesting, and information can be made multi-dimensional.  You can see relationships, connections and it gives concept maps a new meaning.
  • That you can allow other people to edit your Prezi. (Up to 8 people)

How could Prezi be used in a classroom?
Prezi's could be used for many different things in the classroom.  They could be either set up by a teacher to demonstrate relationships within a topic or focus on the most important points of a topic.  Prezi allows you to focus on specific words or images and then focus again further on a diagram or picture that gives students further information.   Prezi could also be used by students as a way of presenting their work.

I had a look around the web to see what other teachers are using them for in the classroom and this is what I came up with.  

Stephanie Greer (2011, Mar 8) -http://clickbrick.wordpress.com/tag/education/ 
  • Telling Stories,
  • Embedding YouTube videos (so no advertising), 
  • Checking comprehension using simple assessments.
Jonathan Jarc (2010, Sept 6) - http://trendingeducation.com/?p=326  
  • As an alternative to PowerPoint.
and a few other ideas:
  •  Concept maps.
  •  Presentations.
Theory behind its use
Prezi presentations support the use of cognitive thinking skills in students.  The Prezi format assists students to remember knowledge if text and visuals are used together.  Lane and Wright (2012, p.4) are discussing PowerPoint however this is also true for Prezi.  They say " if you can simultaneously show what you say, regardless of where the interaction leads, your message will take on greater significance."

According to Mayer and Moreno (n.d) multimedia design should follow a set of principles that are important to students learning and understanding.  They base their research on cognitive theory of learning.  The five principles are as follows. 
  1. Multiple Representation Principle:  It is better to present an explanation in words and pictures than solely in words. 
  2. Contiguity Principle: When giving a multimedia explanation, present corresponding
    words and pictures contiguously rather than separately.  
  3. Split-Attention Principle: When giving a multimedia explanation, present words as
    auditory narration rather than as visual on-screen text.
  4. Individual Differences Principle: The foregoing principles are more important for low knowledge than high-knowledge learners, and for high-spatial rather than low-spatial learners.
  5. Coherence Principle: When giving a multimedia explanation, use few rather than  many extraneous words and pictures (Mayer and Moreno, n.d).
Prezi can also support constructivist thinking through collaboration.  For example; if students are using Prezi to present their groups assignment or project, than students are having to communicate, exchange ideas and work together to complete the task.  This way of working is student centred.  The great benefit of Prezi is that it is an online format that supports up to 8 people adding information.  This allows students more freedom to work on it at school or in a home setting.

Prezi verses Powerpoint  
After doing some research on the web about what others think of Prezi compared to PowerPoint there appears to be a consensus that prezi does not have more benefits over PowerPoint.  Roberts (2011, Dec 15) says,"I believe Prezi has a place within a presenter’s box of tools. But once the hype dies down, I don’t think its place will be a privileged one in any sense."  Veer (2012, Feb 18) suggests that the only real advantage of Prezi is that it " encourages (almost forces) an integrative and holistic means of presenting, it is far easier to show a student how the whole lecture/seminar fits together." but he goes on to point out that "I don't see the point to Prezi over PowerPoint, pedagogically. (Veer 2012, Feb 18).  Veer (2012, Feb 18) and Jarc (2010, Sept 6) point out that there are only a few font and design options and these are basic.

Clark (2011, Sept 26) below has completed a detailed table of the differences.


PowerPoint-vs-Prezi
I have come to the conclusion after using Prezi and through my research, that Prezi does have a place in education presentations.  The designer of the presentation however, really needs to think about whether the presentation needs to be linear like PowerPoint or non linear like Prezi.  I think Prezi really has a place in presenting complex concept maps to assist students to see relationships between knowledge.  It also has a place to help students collaborate on the presentation of assessment topics.  Of course for this collaboration to work well task allocation and student rules around editing would need to be explicitly stated at the beginning.

Reference List
Clark,C. (2011, Sept 26). Powerpoint verses Prezi. Retrieved from http://www.scribd.com/doc/51295596/PowerPoint-vs-Prezi

Greer, S. (2011, Mar 8). Using Prezi in the early elementary classroom. Retrieved from http://clickbrick.wordpress.com/tag/education/

Jarc, J. (2010, Sept 6) Use a Prezi as an alternative to PowerPoint. Retrieved from  http://trendingeducation.com/?p=326

Lane, R. & Wright, R. (2012) And the research says? PowerPoint meets cognitive science. Retrieved from http://office.microsoft.com/en-us/powerpoint-help/and-the-research-says-powerpoint-meets-cognitive-science-HA010198311.aspx?CTT=1

Mayer, R.E. and Moreno, R. (n.d) A cognitive theory of multimedia learning: Implications for design principles. Retrieved from http://www.unm.edu/~moreno/PDFS/chi.pdf

Roberts, M. (2011, Dec 15). Prezi with a grain of salt. Retrieved from  http://idelthoughts.tumblr.com/post/14271052343/prezi-with-a-grain-of-salt

Veer, E. (2012, Feb 18). Why Prezi won't revolutionize your presentations. Retrieved from http://academipad.joachim-scholz.com/2012/02/18/why-prezi-wont-revolutionize-your-presentations/



No comments:

Post a Comment